list (version 9.2.6)

predict.ictreg: Predict Method for Item Count Technique

Description

Function to calculate predictions and uncertainties of predictions from estimates from multivariate regression analysis of survey data with the item count technique.

Usage

# S3 method for ictreg
predict(
  object,
  newdata,
  newdata.diff,
  direct.glm,
  newdata.direct,
  se.fit = FALSE,
  interval = c("none", "confidence"),
  level = 0.95,
  avg = FALSE,
  sensitive.item,
  ...
)

Value

predict.ictreg produces a vector of predictions or a matrix of predictions and bounds with column names fit, lwr, and upr if interval is set. If se.fit is TRUE, a list with the following components is returned:

fit

vector or matrix as above

se.fit

standard error of prediction

Arguments

object

Object of class inheriting from "ictreg"

newdata

An optional data frame containing data that will be used to make predictions from. If omitted, the data used to fit the regression are used.

newdata.diff

An optional data frame used to compare predictions with predictions from the data in the provided newdata data frame.

direct.glm

A glm object from a logistic binomial regression predicting responses to a direct survey item regarding the sensitive item. The predictions from the ictreg object are compared to the predictions based on this glm object.

newdata.direct

An optional data frame used for predictions from the direct.glm logistic regression fit.

se.fit

A switch indicating if standard errors are required.

interval

Type of interval calculation.

level

Significance level for confidence intervals.

avg

A switch indicating if the mean prediction and associated statistics across all obserations in the dataframe will be returned instead of predictions for each observation.

sensitive.item

For multiple sensitive item design list experiments, specify which sensitive item fits to use for predictions. Default is the first sensitive item.

...

further arguments to be passed to or from other methods.

Author

Graeme Blair, UCLA, and Kosuke Imai, Princeton University,

Details

predict.ictreg produces predicted values, obtained by evaluating the regression function in the frame newdata (which defaults to model.frame(object). If the logical se.fit is TRUE, standard errors of the predictions are calculated. Setting interval specifies computation of confidence intervals at the specified level or no intervals.

If avg is set to TRUE, the mean prediction across all observations in the dataset will be calculated, and if the se.fit option is set to TRUE a standard error for this mean estimate will be provided. The interval option will output confidence intervals instead of only the point estimate if set to TRUE.

Two additional types of mean prediction are also available. The first, if a newdata.diff data frame is provided by the user, calculates the mean predicted values across two datasets, as well as the mean difference in predicted value. Standard errors and confidence intervals can also be added. For difference prediction, avg must be set to TRUE.

The second type of prediction, triggered if a direct.glm object is provided by the user, calculates the mean difference in prediction between predictions based on an ictreg fit and a glm fit from a direct survey item on the sensitive question. This is defined as the revealed social desirability bias in Blair and Imai (2010).

References

Blair, Graeme and Kosuke Imai. (2012) ``Statistical Analysis of List Experiments." Political Analysis, Vol. 20, No 1 (Winter). available at http://imai.princeton.edu/research/listP.html

Imai, Kosuke. (2011) ``Multivariate Regression Analysis for the Item Count Technique.'' Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 106, No. 494 (June), pp. 407-416. available at http://imai.princeton.edu/research/list.html

See Also

ictreg for model fitting

Examples

data(race)

race.south <- race.nonsouth <- race

race.south[, "south"] <- 1
race.nonsouth[, "south"] <- 0

if (FALSE) {

# Fit EM algorithm ML model with constraint with no covariates

ml.results.south.nocov <- ictreg(y ~ 1, 
   data = race[race$south == 1, ], method = "ml", treat = "treat", 
   J = 3, overdispersed = FALSE, constrained = TRUE)
ml.results.nonsouth.nocov <- ictreg(y ~ 1, 
   data = race[race$south == 0, ], method = "ml", treat = "treat", 
   J = 3, overdispersed = FALSE, constrained = TRUE)

# Calculate average predictions for respondents in the South 
# and the the North of the US for the MLE no covariates 
# model, replicating the estimates presented in Figure 1, 
# Imai (2010)

avg.pred.south.nocov <- predict(ml.results.south.nocov,
   newdata = as.data.frame(matrix(1, 1, 1)), se.fit = TRUE, 
   avg = TRUE)
avg.pred.nonsouth.nocov <- predict(ml.results.nonsouth.nocov,
   newdata = as.data.frame(matrix(1, 1, 1)), se.fit = TRUE, 
   avg = TRUE)

# Fit linear regression

lm.results <- ictreg(y ~ south + age + male + college, 
   data = race, treat = "treat", J=3, method = "lm")

# Calculate average predictions for respondents in the 
# South and the the North of the US for the lm model, 
# replicating the estimates presented in Figure 1, Imai (2010)

avg.pred.south.lm <- predict(lm.results, newdata = race.south, 
   se.fit = TRUE, avg = TRUE)

avg.pred.nonsouth.lm <- predict(lm.results, newdata = race.nonsouth, 
   se.fit = TRUE, avg = TRUE)

# Fit two-step non-linear least squares regression

nls.results <- ictreg(y ~ south + age + male + college, 
   data = race, treat = "treat", J=3, method = "nls")

# Calculate average predictions for respondents in the South 
# and the the North of the US for the NLS model, replicating
# the estimates presented in Figure 1, Imai (2010)

avg.pred.nls <- predict(nls.results, newdata = race.south, 
   newdata.diff = race.nonsouth, se.fit = TRUE, avg = TRUE)

# Fit EM algorithm ML model with constraint

ml.constrained.results <- ictreg(y ~ south + age + male + college, 
   data = race, treat = "treat", J=3, method = "ml", 
   overdispersed = FALSE, constrained = TRUE)

# Calculate average predictions for respondents in the South 
# and the the North of the US for the MLE model, replicating the 
# estimates presented in Figure 1, Imai (2010)

avg.pred.diff.mle <- predict(ml.constrained.results, 
   newdata = race.south, newdata.diff = race.nonsouth,
   se.fit = TRUE, avg = TRUE)

# Calculate average predictions from the item count technique
# regression and from a direct sensitive item modeled with
# a logit.

# Estimate logit for direct sensitive question

data(mis)

mis.list <- subset(mis, list.data == 1)

mis.sens <- subset(mis, sens.data == 1)

# Fit EM algorithm ML model

fit.list <- ictreg(y ~ age + college + male + south,
   J = 4, data = mis.list, method = "ml")

# Fit logistic regression with directly-asked sensitive question

fit.sens <- glm(sensitive ~ age + college + male + south, 
   data = mis.sens, family = binomial("logit"))

# Predict difference between response to sensitive item
# under the direct and indirect questions (the list experiment).
# This is an estimate of the revealed social desirability bias
# of respondents. See Blair and Imai (2010).

avg.pred.social.desirability <- predict(fit.list, 
   direct.glm = fit.sens, se.fit = TRUE)

}