noharm.sirt: NOHARM Model in R

Description

The function is an R implementation of the normal ogive harmonic analysis robust method (the NOHARM model; McDonald, 1997). Exploratory and confirmatory multidimensional item response models for dichotomous data using the probit link function can be estimated. Lower asymptotes (guessing parameters) and upper asymptotes (one minus slipping parameters) can be provided as fixed values.

Usage

noharm.sirt(dat, pm=NULL, N=NULL, weights=NULL, Fval=NULL, Fpatt=NULL, Pval=NULL,
   Ppatt=NULL, Psival=NULL, Psipatt=NULL, dimensions=NULL, lower=0, upper=1, wgtm=NULL,
   pos.loading=FALSE, pos.variance=FALSE, pos.residcorr=FALSE, maxiter=1000, conv=1e-6,
   optimizer="nlminb", par_lower=NULL, reliability=FALSE, ...)
# S3 method for noharm.sirt
summary(object, file=NULL, ...)

Value

A list. The most important entries are

tanaka: Tanaka fit statistic
rmsr: RMSR fit statistic
N.itempair: Sample size per item pair
pm: Product moment matrix
wgtm: Matrix of weights for each item pair
sumwgtm: Sum of lower triangle matrix wgtm
lower: Lower asymptotes
upper: Upper asymptotes
residuals: Residual matrix from approximation of the pm matrix
final.constants: Final constants
factor.cor: Covariance matrix
thresholds: Threshold parameters
uniquenesses: Uniquenesses
loadings: Matrix of standardized factor loadings (delta parametrization)
loadings.theta: Matrix of factor loadings $\bold{F}$ (theta parametrization)
residcorr: Matrix of residual correlations
Nobs: Number of observations
Nitems: Number of items
Fpatt: Pattern loading matrix for $\bold{F}$
Ppatt: Pattern loading matrix for $\bold{P}$
Psipatt: Pattern loading matrix for $\bold{\Psi}$
dat: Used dataset
dimensions: Number of dimensions
iter: Number of iterations
Nestpars: Number of estimated parameters
chisquare: Statistic $\chi^2$
df: Degrees of freedom
chisquare_df: Ratio $\chi^2 / df$
rmsea: RMSEA statistic
p.chisquare: Significance for $\chi^2$ statistic
omega.rel: Reliability of the sum score according to Green and Yang (2009)

Arguments

dat: Matrix of dichotomous item responses. This matrix may contain missing data (indicated by NA) but missingness is assumed to be missing completely at random (MCAR). Alternatively, a product-moment matrix pm can be used as input.
pm: Optional product-moment matrix
N: Sample size if pm is provided
weights: Optional vector of student weights.
Fval: Initial or fixed values of the loading matrix $\bold{F}$.
Fpatt: Pattern matrix of the loading matrix $\bold{F}$. If elements should be estimated, then an entry of 1 must be included in the pattern matrix. Parameters which should be estimated with equality constraints must be indicated by same integers but values largers than 1.
Pval: Initial or fixed values for the covariance matrix $\bold{P}$.
Ppatt: Pattern matrix for the covariance matrix $\bold{P}$.
Psival: Initial or fixed values for the matrix of residual correlations $\bold{\Psi}$.
Psipatt: Pattern matrix for the matrix of residual correlations $\bold{\Psi}$.
dimensions: Number of dimensions if an exploratory factor analysis should be estimated.
lower: Fixed vector (or numeric) of lower asymptotes $c_i$.
upper: Fixed vector (or numeric) of upper asymptotes $d_i$.
wgtm: Matrix with positive entries which indicates by a positive entry which item pairs should be used for estimation.
pos.loading: An optional logical indicating whether all entries in the loading matrix $\bold{F}$ should be positive
pos.variance: An optional logical indicating whether all variances (i.e. diagonal entries in $\bold{P}$) should be positive
pos.residcorr: An optional logical indicating whether all entries in the matrix of residual correlations $\bold{\Psi}$ should be positive
par_lower: Optional vector of lower parameter bounds
maxiter: Maximum number of iterations
conv: Convergence criterion for parameters
optimizer: Optimization function to be used. Can be "nlminb" for stats::nlminb or "optim" for stats::optim.
reliability: Logical indicating whether reliability should be computed.
...: Further arguments to be passed.
object: Object of class noharm.sirt
file: String indicating a file name for summary.

Details

The NOHARM item response model follows the response equation $$P( X_{pi}=1 | \bold{\theta}_p )=c_i + ( d_i - c_i ) \Phi( f_{i0} + f_{i1} \theta_{p1} + ... + f_{iD} \theta_{pD} ) $$ for item responses $X_{pi}$ of person $p$ on item $i$, $\bold{F}=(f_{id})$ is a loading matrix and $\bold{P}$ the covariance matrix of $\bold{\theta}_p$. The lower asymptotes $c_i$ and upper asymptotes $d_i$ must be provided as fixed values. The response equation can be equivalently written by introducing a latent continuous item response $X_{pi}^\ast$ $$ X_{pi}^\ast=f_{i0} + f_{i1} \theta_{p1} + ... + f_{iD} \theta_{pD} + e_{pi} $$ with a standard normally distributed residual $e_{pi}$. These residuals have a correlation matrix $\bold{\Psi}$ with ones in the diagonal. In this R implementation of the NOHARM model, correlations between residuals are allowed.

The estimation relies on a Hermite series approximation of the normal ogive item response functions. In more detail, a series expansion $$\Phi(x)=b_0 + b_1 H_1(x) + b_2 H_2(x) + b_3 H_3(x)$$ is used (McDonald, 1982a). This enables to express cross products $p_{ij}=P(X_i=1, X_j=1)$ as a function of unknown model parameters $$\hat{p}_{ij}=b_{0i} b_{0j} + \sum_{m=1}^3 b_{mi} b_{mj} \left( \frac{\bold{f}_i \bold{P} \bold{f}_j }{\sqrt{ (1+\bold{f}_i \bold{P} \bold{f}_i) (1+\bold{f}_j \bold{P} \bold{f}_j)}} \right) ^m $$ where $b_{0i}=p_{i}=P(X_i=1)=c_i + (d_i - c_i) \Phi(\tau_i)$, $b_{1i}=(d_i-c_i)\phi(\tau_i)$, $b_{2i}=(d_i-c_i)\tau_i \phi(\tau_i) / \sqrt{2}$, and $b_{3i}=(d_i-c_i)(\tau_i^2 - 1)\phi(\tau_i) / \sqrt{6}$.

The least squares criterion $\sum_{i<j} ( p_{ij} - \hat{p}_{ij})^2$ is used for estimating unknown model parameters (McDonald, 1982a, 1982b, 1997).

For derivations of standard errors and fit statistics see Maydeu-Olivares (2001) and Swaminathan and Rogers (2016).

For the statistical properties of the NOHARM approach see Knol and Berger (1991), Finch (2011) or Svetina and Levy (2016).

References

Finch, H. (2011). Multidimensional item response theory parameter estimation with nonsimple structure items. Applied Psychological Measurement, 35(1), 67-82. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1177/0146621610367787")

Fraser, C., & McDonald, R. P. (1988). NOHARM: Least squares item factor analysis. Multivariate Behavioral Research, 23, 267-269. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1207/s15327906mbr2302_9")

Fraser, C., & McDonald, R. P. (2012). NOHARM 4 Manual.
http://noharm.niagararesearch.ca/nh4man/nhman.html.

Knol, D. L., & Berger, M. P. (1991). Empirical comparison between factor analysis and multidimensional item response models. Multivariate Behavioral Research, 26(3), 457-477. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1207/s15327906mbr2603_5")

Maydeu-Olivares, A. (2001). Multidimensional item response theory modeling of binary data: Large sample properties of NOHARM estimates. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 26(1), 51-71. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.3102/10769986026001051")

McDonald, R. P. (1982a). Linear versus nonlinear models in item response theory. Applied Psychological Measurement, 6(4), 379-396. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1177/014662168200600402")

McDonald, R. P. (1982b). Unidimensional and multidimensional models for item response theory. I.R.T., C.A.T. conference, Minneapolis, 1982, Proceedings.

McDonald, R. P. (1997). Normal-ogive multidimensional model. In W. van der Linden & R. K. Hambleton (1997): Handbook of modern item response theory (pp. 257-269). New York: Springer. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1007/978-1-4757-2691-6")

Svetina, D., & Levy, R. (2016). Dimensionality in compensatory MIRT when complex structure exists: Evaluation of DETECT and NOHARM. The Journal of Experimental Education, 84(2), 398-420. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1080/00220973.2015.1048845")

Swaminathan, H., & Rogers, H. J. (2016). Normal-ogive multidimensional models. In W. J. van der Linden (Ed.). Handbook of item response theory. Volume One: Models (pp. 167-187). Boca Raton: CRC Press. tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1201/9781315374512")

Examples

Run this code

#############################################################################
# EXAMPLE 1: Two-dimensional IRT model with 10 items
#############################################################################

#**** data simulation
set.seed(9776)
N <- 3400 # sample size
# define difficulties
f0 <- c( .5, .25, -.25, -.5, 0, -.5, -.25, .25, .5, 0 )
I <- length(f0)
# define loadings
f1 <- matrix( 0, I, 2 )
f1[ 1:5,1] <- c(.8,.7,.6,.5, .5)
f1[ 6:10,2] <- c(.8,.7,.6,.5, .5 )
# covariance matrix
Pval <- matrix( c(1,.5,.5,1), 2, 2 )
# simulate theta
library(mvtnorm)
theta <- mvtnorm::rmvnorm(N, mean=c(0,0), sigma=Pval )
# simulate item responses
dat <- matrix( NA, N, I )
for (ii in 1:I){ # ii <- 1
    dat[,ii] <- 1*( stats::pnorm(f0[ii]+theta[,1]*f1[ii,1]+theta[,2]*f1[ii,2])>
                     stats::runif(N) )
        }
colnames(dat) <- paste0("I", 1:I)

#**** Model 1: Two-dimensional CFA with estimated item loadings
# define pattern matrices
Pval <- .3+0*Pval
Ppatt <- 1*(Pval>0)
diag(Ppatt) <- 0
diag(Pval) <- 1
Fval <- .7 * ( f1>0)
Fpatt <- 1 * ( Fval > 0 )
# estimate model
mod1 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt, Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval )
summary(mod1)
# EAP ability estimates
pmod1 <- sirt::R2noharm.EAP(mod1, theta.k=seq(-4,4,len=10) )
# model fit
summary( sirt::modelfit.sirt(mod1) )

if (FALSE) {
#*** compare results with NOHARM software
noharm.path <- "c:/NOHARM"   # specify path for noharm software
mod1a <- sirt::R2noharm( dat=dat, model.type="CFA",  F.pattern=Fpatt, F.init=Fval,
             P.pattern=Ppatt, P.init=Pval, writename="r2noharm_example",
             noharm.path=noharm.path, dec="," )
summary(mod1a)

#**** Model 1c: put some equality constraints
Fpatt[ c(1,4),1] <- 3
Fpatt[ cbind( c(3,7), c(1,2)) ] <- 4
mod1c <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt, Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval)
summary(mod1c)

#**** Model 2: Two-dimensional CFA with correlated residuals
# define pattern matrix for residual correlation
Psipatt <- 0*diag(I)
Psipatt[1,2] <- 1
Psival <- 0*Psipatt
# estimate model
mod2 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval,
            Psival=Psival, Psipatt=Psipatt )
summary(mod2)

#**** Model 3: Two-dimensional Rasch model
# pattern matrices
Fval <- matrix(0,10,2)
Fval[1:5,1] <- Fval[6:10,2] <- 1
Fpatt <- 0*Fval
Ppatt <- Pval <- matrix(1,2,2)
Pval[1,2] <- Pval[2,1] <- 0
# estimate model
mod3 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval )
summary(mod3)
# model fit
summary( sirt::modelfit.sirt( mod3 ))

#** compare fit with NOHARM
noharm.path <- "c:/NOHARM"
P.pattern <- Ppatt ; P.init <- Pval
F.pattern <- Fpatt ; F.init <- Fval
mod3b <- sirt::R2noharm( dat=dat, model.type="CFA",
             F.pattern=F.pattern, F.init=F.init, P.pattern=P.pattern,
             P.init=P.init, writename="example_sim_2dim_rasch",
             noharm.path=noharm.path, dec="," )
summary(mod3b)

#############################################################################
# EXAMPLE 2: data.read
#############################################################################

data(data.read)
dat <- data.read
I <- ncol(dat)

#**** Model 1: Unidimensional Rasch model
Fpatt <- matrix( 0, I, 1 )
Fval <- 1 + 0*Fpatt
Ppatt <- Pval <- matrix(1,1,1)
# estimate model
mod1 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval )
summary(mod1)
plot(mod1)    # semPaths plot

#**** Model 2: Rasch model in which item pairs within a testlet are excluded
wgtm <- matrix( 1, I, I )
wgtm[1:4,1:4] <- wgtm[5:8,5:8] <- wgtm[ 9:12, 9:12] <- 0
# estimation
mod2 <- sirt::noharm.sirt(dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval, wgtm=wgtm)
summary(mod2)

#**** Model 3: Rasch model with correlated residuals
Psipatt <- Psival <- 0*diag(I)
Psipatt[1:4,1:4] <- Psipatt[5:8,5:8] <- Psipatt[ 9:12, 9:12] <- 1
diag(Psipatt) <- 0
Psival <- .6*(Psipatt>0)
# estimation
mod3 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval,
            Psival=Psival, Psipatt=Psipatt )
summary(mod3)
# allow only positive residual correlations
mod3b <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt, Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval,
            Psival=Psival, Psipatt=Psipatt, pos.residcorr=TRUE)
summary(mod3b)
#* constrain residual correlations
Psipatt[1:4,1:4] <- 2
Psipatt[5:8,5:8] <- 3
Psipatt[ 9:12, 9:12] <- 4
mod3c <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt, Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval,
            Psival=Psival, Psipatt=Psipatt, pos.residcorr=TRUE)
summary(mod3c)

#**** Model 4: Rasch testlet model
Fval <- Fpatt <- matrix( 0, I, 4 )
Fval[,1] <- Fval[1:4,2] <- Fval[5:8,3] <- Fval[9:12,4 ] <- 1
Ppatt <- Pval <- diag(4)
colnames(Ppatt) <- c("g", "A", "B","C")
Pval <- .5*Pval
# estimation
mod4 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval  )
summary(mod4)
# allow only positive variance entries
mod4b <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval,
               pos.variance=TRUE )
summary(mod4b)

#**** Model 5: Bifactor model
Fval <- matrix( 0, I, 4 )
Fval[,1] <- Fval[1:4,2] <- Fval[5:8,3] <- Fval[9:12,4 ] <- .6
Fpatt <- 1 * ( Fval > 0 )
Pval <- diag(4)
Ppatt <- 0*Pval
colnames(Ppatt) <- c("g", "A", "B","C")
# estimation
mod5 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval  )
summary(mod5)
# allow only positive loadings
mod5b <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval,
              pos.loading=TRUE )
summary(mod5b)
summary( sirt::modelfit.sirt(mod5b))

#**** Model 6: 3-dimensional Rasch model
Fval <- matrix( 0, I, 3 )
Fval[1:4,1] <- Fval[5:8,2] <- Fval[9:12,3 ] <- 1
Fpatt <- 0*Fval
Pval <- .6*diag(3)
diag(Pval) <- 1
Ppatt <- 1+0*Pval
colnames(Ppatt) <- c("A", "B","C")
# estimation
mod6 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval  )
summary(mod6)
summary( sirt::modelfit.sirt(mod6) )  # model fit

#**** Model 7: 3-dimensional 2PL model
Fval <- matrix( 0, I, 3 )
Fval[1:4,1] <- Fval[5:8,2] <- Fval[9:12,3 ] <- 1
Fpatt <- Fval
Pval <- .6*diag(3)
diag(Pval) <- 1
Ppatt <- 1+0*Pval
diag(Ppatt) <- 0
colnames(Ppatt) <- c("A", "B","C")
# estimation
mod7 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, Ppatt=Ppatt,Fpatt=Fpatt, Fval=Fval, Pval=Pval  )
summary(mod7)
summary( sirt::modelfit.sirt(mod7) )

#**** Model 8: Exploratory factor analysis with 3 dimensions
# estimation
mod8 <- sirt::noharm.sirt( dat=dat, dimensions=3  )
summary(mod8)

#############################################################################
# EXAMPLE 3: Product-moment matrix input, McDonald (1997)
#############################################################################

# data from Table 1 of McDonald (1997, p. 266)
pm0 <- "
0.828
0.567 0.658
0.664 0.560 0.772
0.532 0.428 0.501 0.606
0.718 0.567 0.672 0.526 0.843
"
pm <- miceadds::string_to_matrix(x=pm0, as_numeric=TRUE, extend=TRUE)
I <- nrow(pm)
rownames(pm) <- colnames(pm) <- paste0("I", 1:I)

#- Model 1: Unidimensional model
Fval <- matrix(.7, nrow=I, ncol=1)
Fpatt <- 1+0*Fval
Pval <- matrix(1, nrow=1,ncol=1)
Ppatt <- 0*Pval

mod1 <- sirt::noharm.sirt(pm=pm, N=1000, Fval=Fval, Fpatt=Fpatt, Pval=Pval, Ppatt=Ppatt)
summary(mod1)

#- Model 2: Twodimensional exploratory model
mod2 <- sirt::noharm.sirt(pm=pm, N=1000, dimensions=2)
summary(mod2)

#- Model 3: Unidimensional model with correlated residuals
Psival <- matrix(0, nrow=I, ncol=I)
Psipatt <- 0*Psival
Psipatt[5,1] <- 1

mod3 <- sirt::noharm.sirt(pm=pm, N=1000, Fval=Fval, Fpatt=Fpatt, Pval=Pval, Ppatt=Ppatt,
            Psival=Psival, Psipatt=Psipatt)
summary(mod3)
}

Run the code above in your browser using DataLab